2010年1月16日星期六

The Underlying Tragedy ----by Helen

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/15/opinion/15brooks.html?bl

The devastation from the earthquake in Haiti should be used as an occasion to rethink our approach to global poverty. First of all, we don't really know how to use aid to reduce poverty. Countries that haven't got much aid, like China, have been developing fast and there are tremendous poverty reduction; while countries that have received aid, like Haiti, have not. Secondly, micro-aid is vital but insufficient. Thirdly, culture should be focus on to tackle global poverty. Haiti is poor because of its history of oppression, slaverty and colonialism, as well as the influence of the voodoo religion. Fourth, it's time to promote locally led paternalism. In all, this earthquake is a trauma for cultures to change.

These are all good thoughts but yet the earthquake happened. Although many of the observations are perhaps true, what is needed now is compassion and pratical help. Probably the mistake of " throwing money at it" is true, but it is the wrong time to say so. Because right now, money means food; money means water; money means docters; money means life.

After the disaster, maybe it is the right time to think about this tragedy. It is true that powerful countries are becoming richer and richer; while weak countires are turning poorer and poorer.
Haiti is basically just a destitute version of most countries in the world today, while a wealthy, corrupt minority maintains a system that leaves the impoverished majority worring more about their next meal than their govenment. In my own point of view, America, as the superpower in the world, has a moral obligation to offer as much help as possible, but after the rubble is cleared and the bodies buried, the simple truth is that only Haitians themselves can change Haiti. They have a corrupt government that must be dealt with and removed, which they can only depend on themselves and no one can help.

1 条评论:

  1. Alex commmenting: I totally agree with your last sentence "they can only depend on themselves and no one can help."
    Many poor countries are receiving financial help from the superpowers, however, because of the obsolete government system and an uneducated majority which have contributed to the huge corruptions within those countries, the people's lives in underdeveloped countries have not been ameliorated at all.
    However, I don't think help from the U.S. is gonna change anything in Haiti, unless the U.S. takes over the Haiti government... Haitians have to deal with their own problems, but not always expect some superpowers to save them. After all, every country is selfish. U.S. is not going to help them without getting certain benefits in return...
    BTW, China donates a lot of money to African countries; it's not out of pure sympathy... Mainland China needs their votes in UN to keep Taiwan out of the UN...

    回复删除